Wix or Squarespace vs a Web Designer: The Real Cost Over 3 Years
Closer than the sticker prices suggest: over three years a "cheap" builder site typically costs $1,800–$3,600 in cash plus 30–60+ hours of your own time, while a professionally built site runs $3,400–$11,000 all-in with your hours near zero. The bigger differences are who does the work and what you own at the end.
The sticker price vs the real price
"$39 a month" is a subscription that never ends and doesn't include the work; "$4,000" is the work. To compare them you have to price three years of subscriptions, the apps that turn a basic plan into a useful one, and the only cost people never write down: their own evenings. That last line is where the comparison flips for most business owners.
The three-year bill, line by line
| Cost | Builder (Wix / Squarespace) | Professionally built |
|---|---|---|
| Plan / hosting | $30–60 a month, forever | $10–30 a month hosting |
| The build itself | Your evenings and weekends | $3,000–10,000 once |
| Apps and add-ons | $10–40 a month, creeps up | Usually built in |
| Your hours (setup + upkeep) | 30–60+ hours | Near zero |
| Three-year total | $1,800–3,600 + your hours | $3,400–11,000 all-in |
Where the money goes over three years
Same three years, two very different shapes of spending:
The costs nobody mentions on the pricing page
Five lines missing from the builder brochure:
- Transaction fees: store plans commonly skim a percentage of every sale on top of the payment processor's cut.
- Template lock-in: a redesign later usually means rebuilding from scratch inside the builder, not tweaking what you have.
- You can't take it with you: leave the platform and the site stays behind. There's no export of a working website; you start again.
- The SEO ceiling: you can rank with a builder site, but limited control over speed and structure means fighting the platform on exactly the things Google measures.
- The "free" domain: free for year one, renewed at a premium after, and occasionally registered in a way that makes it painful to move.
The exit is the real price tag
The biggest difference between the two paths shows up the day you want to leave:
What if you hire a designer to build it on Squarespace?
There's a middle path: pay a designer to set up the builder site for you. In Australia that typically runs $1,000–$5,000 for a Squarespace or Wix build, depending on pages and polish, plus the subscription, which keeps running. It solves the your-evenings problem, and for a simple site on a tight budget it can be a fair deal. Go in knowing you've paid for the setup only. The template limits, monthly fees and lock-in from the table above all still apply, and at the top of that price range you're already in custom-build territory.
When a builder is the right call
If you're testing an idea and don't know whether the business will exist in a year, use a builder. Same if the budget simply isn't there yet, or you enjoy tinkering and your needs are a page with hours and a phone number. A $39-a-month experiment beats a $5,000 commitment to an unproven idea.
When a designer pays for itself
The switch point is when being found and chosen starts driving real revenue. For most trades and services, one extra job a month covers the difference several times over. At that point the professional build wins: it ranks better, converts better and takes none of your week. You also own the result outright: code, domain and content, all portable.
Where to next
- Urban Toolboxes: a 99-product catalogue no template could hold
The kind of build that decides the builder-vs-designer question.
See the professional numbers for yourself
Our pricing is public, with fixed figures and what's included at each tier. Compare it against three years of subscriptions and your own hours.
Common Questions
Some of the sites we've built
All projects
